|
Barbara Adams Kangchenjunga Tea Estate has been the name
on the label of organic tea to which I am addicted. Therefore, when invited to visit a
remote part of eastern Nepal where this tea is grown curiosity got the better of me, and I
accepted. Nepalis drink lots of tea. Most of the tea
is sprayed with lots of chemicals. The fact that Nepalis now have a choice to avoid tea
laced with carcinogenic chemicals is credit to the man whose dream it is to turn Nepal
back into its organic farming origins: Dipak Banskota. The trip turned out to be more of an
adventure than we expected. It took us four vehicles, eight bottles of mineral water, one
bulldozer and nerves of steel to get from Biratnagar to Phidim. If you think remote areas
of Nepal today are different from Nepal 40 years ago, you should have been with us. First disaster: total brake failure
two-thrids of the way to Ilam on on Banskotas ageing Toyota Landcruiser. We crawled
on first gear and trepidation through a Hollywood-like thunderstorm. In Ilam we found
refuge in a hotel located at what passed for the local bus park. Awakened at four by buses
screaming their horns off, we walked through Nepals oldest tea plantation at five.
The sculptured hills of tea glowed like striated green velvet. Tea is as good to look at
as it is to drink. We abandoned the Toyota and set out for
Phidim in a borrowed pickup. Almost immediately the skies opened up and dumped a
suppressed monsoon downpour on us. The rain finally abated for us to note with shock that
some hundred meters ahead of us the road had disappeared. It had become a mountain of mud
and tangled trees. The landslide had happened only ten minutes earlier, according to the
driver of the only other vehicle stopped on our side. On the Phidim side was an ambulance
with critically ill man who was being transferred to the hospital in Dharan. Decision: Do we climb over the debris and
find a vehicle on the other side, or do we retreat and try to find a bulldozer? We decided
on the latter. Thanks to the resourcefulness and the many friends and Dipaks
relatives in the area, someone who knew someone in charge of road clearing was found. Half
an hour later as we sipped inorganic tea, we saw some very professional looking
road-clearing machinery speeding towards the mud slide. One hour later the road was clear
and we were past the disaster area, but the ambulance with its ailing passenger was still
stuck. The driver of the bus directly in front of the ambulance had chosen this crucial
time to disappear to an unknown destination for some tea! Dipak is the leader of the cooperative
movement in Nepal. Clearly truck drivers too need to learn about cooperation. Fortunately
the resourceful Dipak managed to coax the many waiting vehicles and drivers to move a few
feet in one direction or another until the ambulance was finally freed to go on its way.
We too, were freed, but not for long. About one kilometer ahead on the
challenging dirt road was a sea of deep furrowed mud. A truck on the oncoming lane had
been caught, had lost a wheel and had been abandoned. Our lane had furrows too deep to
maneuver. Our driver understandably panicked and backed out of the way of the line of
lumbering trucks which had been following us from the mudslide site. They all ground to a
halt and shovels and manpower were somehow squeezed us and our baggage in between its own
shovel wielding crew. It was my first experience in 37 years in Nepal, riding in the
front of a Tata truck. We were just beginning to relax when suddenly lights throughout the trucks interior began to flash and an ex shovel-wielder near me seemed to be trying to set a fire within the truck. On the dashboard were wildly gyrating red lights and over my head, slightly less alarming pastel colored ones. When the radio came on full blast with a religious Bhajan I realized that my neighbor wasnt lighting fires, he was lighting incense sticks to place near the image of Lord Pashupatinath, I began to relax. On such a road it was not only correct, but necessary to pray for protection. I myself made a silent prayer of thanks. After all, had we not stopped for a cup of tea shortly before the devastating mud slide, we might have been under the mud, instead of free to search for a bulldozer! The truck deposited us in the pouring rain
on an unlit corner of the dirt road somewhere between Phidim and the Tea Cooperative.
There, miraculously, we found a telephone. Half an hour later our fourth and final vehicle
appeared. After negotiating another hair-raising, half-destroyed dirt road, the groaning
tea estate truck deposited us safely at the Kanchenjunga Tea Estate. Nepal is surely a
destination for Adventure Tourism, and our passage to Phidim could qualify! Barbara Adams is a Kathmandu-based writer and columnist. (upload date: June 17) C.
K Lal Deng Xiao Ping said it does not matter if a cat is black or white as long as it catches mice. Deng transformed Mao’s black cat of terror into a meowing white kitten of the free-market. Pol Pot and his Khmer Rouge are history. Many former Naxalites in neighboring India have turned into saffronites. Even the North and South Koreans are talking peace. But in Nepal thousands have been killed in a widening Peoples’ War, and all we are doing is talking about ending it. Congress leaders have been talking about
talks for quite some time now. They talked with fellow-Congressites, they
talked with the main opposition party, and they even hosted a talk-shop
for the nine party front of sundry lefties. However, they have never
talked to the ones that matter: the Maoists. Former Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba is
the man designated to do the talking. All he has been doing so far is
saying that it’s a great idea. One wonders: who is stopping him from
holding talks? Or, is it that all he wants is to keep talking his way into
the Party President’s chair come convention time? Comrade Prachanda also likes to shoot faxes
to the press saying he wants to talk. The day after his warriors
surrounded Panchkatiya Police Post at Dhime VDC in Jajarkot District and
killed one police inspector, twelve policemen and seven innocent
bystanders including women and children, he was busy issuing appeals about
pre-conditions for talks. Home Minister Govinda Raj Joshi gets
straight to the point: Maoists are terrorists so there is no point
discussing anything. Home Minister-aspirant Khum Bahadur Khadka is another
great believer in talks. When the dreaded Operation Kilo Sierra Two
against the Maoists was conducted, they were terrorists for him too,
because he was the Home Minister at that time. Since then, Maoists have
killed a lot more people, and look who is saying what. Anyway, what is
stopping Mr. Khadka from holding talks? He may not be the Home Minister,
but he is supposed to be a senior Congressman. Prime Minister Koirala has gone beyond
talking, he is walking. He has promised to go to the Maoist affected
regions himself, with package programs for development. Pious objective,
no doubt, but it will be better if he did so after installing a worthy
successor in Kathmandu before doing a Jai Prakash Narayan in Jajarkot. President Dwight Eisenhower of United
States of America is once reputed to have said, “Change is the law of
life, and unless there is peaceful change, there is bound to be violent
change.” Ike’s observation is worthy of contemplation by both the
government as well as the rebels. The
mayhem in the name of Maoism has gone for far too long. The time to put a
stop to this madness. If you don’t get into talking terms soon, there
will be nothing to talk about. Enough is enough. Stop giving speeches,
stop discussing modalities, just do it. (upload date: June 18) The People
don’t want war. The Maoists are seemingly
winning the Battle. The big question is: who will win the War that is
being fought in the name of the Nepali people? The Police, isolated in vulnerable forward bases, is in limbo, in the absence of clear orders from its political masters. Not only the government, but the entire opposition and the intelligentsia are confused about what to do. The Police are forced to make do.
But this could change
with the government’s decision to set up a well-equipped paramilitary
force trained by the Army in using automatic rifles and counter-insurgency
tactics, including landmine detection. The paramilitary Armed
Police Force is going to cost about Rs 2 billion and is likely to be ready
for action by late autumn. The budget allocation for the police for the
coming fiscal year has shot up to Rs. 5.3 billion from about Rs. 3 billion
the year before. Both sides, it seems,
want to use a carrot and stick approach. So both are flexing their muscles
to be able to negotiate from a position of strength. The latest humiliation
for Nepal Police occurred on the night of 7 June. The siege and
destruction of the Panchkatia police post in Jajarkot was proof that the
Maoists are escalating their offensives, while maintaining that they are
open to talks. The Maoists are using
classic storming tactics on the ground, and taking full advantage of the
guidanceless Nepal Police’s lack of both motivation and equipment to
fight the insurgency. Then there is the incredibly cynical power tussle
within the ruling Nepali Congress, which the Maoists are using to full
advantage. The Panchkatia attack was
a replay of the classic tactics used by the Maoist insurgents against
police. A group of about 1,000 probably also including villagers allegedly
used as human shields, attacked the outpost from the settlement side. Police said their
51-strong force was unwilling to fire at the attackers for fear of hitting
locals. Using flare-tipped arrows, the Maoists lit up the target and
pelted them with homemade explosives. The police were sitting ducks,
unable to return fire into the darkness with any accuracy. “Our men did the best
they could. When you are pinned down like that, it is difficult to lift
your head to take aim,” said Ram Kaji Bantaba, Additional Inspector
General of Police in charge of operations. Another policeman who has
fought on the frontline: “They attack in waves. If one falls, he is
immediately dragged away and replaced by another.” The latest phase in the
Maoist offensive seems to be a planned attempt to undermine the Nepali
economy as well. Robberies of trekking groups and attacks on a Pokhara
tourist resort in April may well hit the autumn 2000 tourism season hard.
In the past week, key Indian joint ventures in Nepal, Surya Tobacco and
Colgate-Palmolive were firebombed by suspected Maoists in Simara and
Hetauda. It is becoming clear that
the Police is fighting this war with one hand tied behind its back.
Previous operations such as the one code-named “Kilo Sierra Two” last
year cost them local support, and even party politicians in Kathmandu are
unwilling to stick their necks out in support. The mainstay of the
police arsenal is the First World War Enfield “three-knot-three”
single-load rifles. They heat up quickly and jam, and have proven to be no
match to the gelatine charges lobbed by Maoists. The Maoists are taking a
leaf out of their mentor, Mao Zedong, using psychological-warfare tactics
to maximum advantage. Typically, a surprise attack begins with explosions
and deafening chants of revolutionary slogans. Escape routes are sealed
with trip-wire mines and sharpshooters, flares and explosives create
chaos, and lethal explosives hand-crafted from pressure cookers and pipes
are set off. The Maoist arsenal includes knives, clubs, muzzle-loader muskets and rifles taken from the police. What they lack in sophistication, they make up with guerrilla tactics and firepower—thought to be made from the stash of four tons of gelatine that was looted from a construction project in Charikot four years ago.
“Their strategy now is
hit-and-run guerrilla warfare,” said Achyut Krishna Kharel, chief of the
Nepal Police. “We are very visible targets. Police posts are accessible
to all. Anyone can walk in and scout our defences and the trenches. We
cannot withdraw, because our job is to maintain law and order.” During the beginning of
the People’s War there was concern over police atrocities. Now, both
sides have been accused of human rights abuses. Perhaps because of its
earlier role in Kilo Sierra, there is little public sympathy evident for
the Police today when the war started going wrong. Nearly 200 policemen
have been killed since the insurgency began in 1996, with a sharp rise in
deaths since March 1999. Most have been killed in
raids on remote garrisons or blown up by improvised mines along village
trails. As many as 15 policemen were felled in one single attack, at
Ghartigaon in Ropla. The insurgency has cost over 1,300 lives, many of
them civilians caught in the crossfire. Says one senior
policeman: “When Sri Lanka has a civil war, it is the army which
is made to fight. But when there is a similar war brewing in Nepal, the
political parties field a police force with its hands tied. Either the
police has to be empowered to fight like an army, or the army has to be
brought out of the barracks.” After making initial
noise of using the sahi sena, Prime Minister Girija Prasad Koirala has now
retreated. And the Maoists while keeping up the pressure have studiously
kept clear of creating any incident that may raise hackles in the military
brass. It is the ordinary constables, assistant sub-inspectors,
sub-inspectors and inspectors who bear the brunt of this increasingly
brutal war. The first hope that there
may be a resolution came when Comrade Prachanda (Pushpa Kamal Dahal) said
he was willing to talk to the government. That offer may have been made
from a position of strength or weakness, or it may have been a ploy to
gain time, but it was an opportunity to see what the Maoists’ minimum
demands were. Unfortunately, this
opportunity has been all but lost with the tussle for party leadership
between Girija Prasad Koirala and Sher Bahadur Deuba. Over the past week,
Koirala and Deuba have been cynically playing political football with the
possibility of talks. “The talks have not
begun, why argue about the agenda?” Deuba said on June 18. He was
responding to remarks made by Koirala about the need for one to get the
talks started. “Everyone knows about the Maoist agenda, it has appeared
in newspapers,” Deuba added. Home Minister Govinda Raj Joshi, who is
supposed to be commanding the counter-insurgency, knew less. He told
parliament on 13 June: “HMG has no knowledge of what the Maoists’
demands are.” A day after the
Panchkatia killings, Prachanda repeated his demand for the creation of a
“minimum atmosphere” for talks. Deuba responded by saying he was open
to talk about everything within the framework of the constitution. Koirala
had reassured all saying that the Commission headed by Deuba had “full
authority” to talk. Clearly, the Nepali
Congress leadership is playing with the country’s future by not
considering the insurgency with more urgency. The other political parties,
including the main Opposition UML, seem to be content to see the
government squirm. This lack of seriousness means that the body bags
continue to pile up, and a war that the people don’t want rages on. (From
the Nepali Times Demo issue, upload date: June 23/00) Literature
in a Hostile Terrain With a literacy rate near 30 percent, Nepal seems unlikely grounds indeed for those who seek to create imaginary worlds in language. Yet there are hundreds of writers and poets all over the country-an alarming number of whom are concentrated in Kathmandu Valley-who persist in writing despite the fact that no one asks them to write, and no one thanks them for doing so. Writers and poets mirror society and offer new visions that enrich the lives of their readers. In return for the efforts, though, Nepal's creative writers are rarely even paid royalties by publishers, and many must in fact subsidise their own publishing. The established literary magazines of Nepal pay about Rs 500 per story, while most just offer the thrill of seeing one's work in print. To support themselves, writers and poets work as professors, lawyers, bankers, columnists -- even Members of Parliament. Still, few of them can afford to buy foreign books, and must content themselves with borrowing dog-eared copies from friends and from poorly stocked libraries. Those who don't read English scour bookstalls for cheap Hindi translations of world literature, or read only Nepali writings. Women writers, in particular, are so pressed with work and family commitments that they hardly have any free time to write. And for those who live by computers, it is humbling to realise that almost all novels, stories and poems written today are still painstakingly written and revised by hand on foolscap sheets. All this is done for a tiny and utterly indifferent readership: a print run of 1,100 books is the most that a writer can hope for in Nepal, and even then, the free copies are the only books in real demand. Yet Nepal's writers and poets keep writing, thanks mainly, it seems, to an unshakable faith in the worth of their own words. Large egos can sometimes be a blessing. Meeting in tea shops and seedy brew houses, at bookshops and in their offices, today's writers and poets exchange thoughts, opinions, criticism and gossip with great verve. Organisations like the Royal Nepal Academy, as well as other writers' associations and informal groups hold readings, gatherings and literary events all over the country. Many vociferous statements are made on the topic of literature. Small, divergent, sometimes cliquish schools of thought are led by eccentric and often impossibly egotistical personalities. Manifestos are drafted regularly, while movements begin and end abruptly. A shocking number of awards-though most with modest purses-are distributed at many stiff, officious ceremonies. And the number of near-bankrupt literary magazines found in the market would astonish the more money-minded. An impressive variety of voices emerges from all this hectic literary activity. The question "What is Nepal's contemporary literature like?" can be answered with one word: "Diverse." While some of today's writers still favor traditional Sanskrit-derived forms, others opt for either revolutionary or western romanticism, or social realism, or prose of Hemingway-like restraint. Others write predominantly psychological works heavily influenced by Freudian theory. Some poets pen fiery free verse for the masses while others are wildly experimental and abstract in their style. A growing number of writers and poets are writing in their mother tongues, and some regional writers mix languages, reflecting Nepal's multilingual nature. As in much of the world, the writing of the left thrives here, but it cannot be said that there is any one dominant school of literature in today's Nepal. My own view, which I will refrain from tiresomely repeating in this column, is that the literary community of Nepal embodies the postmodern conditions described by current western literary theory. The ancient, the modern and the contemporary are simultaneously present here in ruptured, discontinuous and wholly unexpected ways. There is, I believe, no authoritative place to begin introducing English lay readers to Nepali literature. I'll begin the first article of this column arbitrarily, then, with The Naudanda Hills, a short, compressed poem by Shailendra Sakar that grows evocatively in the reader's mind after the first simple reading. In particular, the old woman in the poem is intriguing: both wily and naive, she is at once a mother figure, huckster and world-weary commentator. She deftly translates the narrator into her son despite his resistance to it. This is one of a series of poems based on places in Sakar's versatile 1990 collection Sarpaharu Geet Gaundainan. It stands, here, as proof that hostile conditions can -remarkably -- inspire and sustain the writing of some excellent literature. THE NAUDANDA
HILLS-
Shailendra Sakar (From
the Nepali Times Demo issue, upload date: June 25/00) By Kunda dixit Breathe easy. Once and
for all, it’s official: Kathmandu Valley’s air pollution is not as bad
as Delhi or Beijing. Now, the bad news. But it
is getting worse, and for now residents have to be more worried about the
dust than the other poisonous gases from vehicles. The other myth shattering
revelation: last year’s ban on diesel three wheelers (Vikram tempos) may
have made the streets look cleaner, but it has not improved air quality
along Kathmandu’s road corridors in any measurable way. "Yes, after the
tempos were gone, you stopped seeing that black smoke on the streets. But
20,000 more vehicles have come onto the roads in Kathmandu after the
Vikrams were banned,” says Toran Sharma of the Nepal Environmental and
Scientific Services (NESS). Latest measurements prove
that the additional vehicles have more than made up for the reduction of
pollution, especially dust in diesel exhaust, after the 350 Vikrams were
banned. NESS has been measuring
Kathmandu Valley’s air pollution levels for the past ten years, ever
since it started becoming a serious health issue. The most recent
monitoring results NESS did for the Asian Development Bank show that
things are much worse than in 1993. “The conclusion is that
Kathmandu valley air quality is degrading, especially with regards to
total suspended particulate matter,” says Sharma. And that means
dust—dust from roadside rubbish, construction materials, digging, diesel
smoke, brick kiln ash, stack emissions from the Himal Cement factory in
Chobar. Air quality measurements
for Kathmandu consistently show that particulate pollution are up to seven
times higher than safe levels set by the World Health Organisation (WHO).
Some 24,000 tons of total suspended particulates are spewed out into the
valley’s atmosphere every year, of which about 7,000 tons are less than
10 microns in size. The main sources of dust
in Kathmandu Valley are (in order of emissions): the brick kilns, Himal
Cement, vehicular pollution, domestic fuel, and roadside rubbish
re-suspension. Even ten years ago,
pollution levels were serious enough for scientists to raise the alarm.
The World Bank’s landmark Urbair Report for Kathmandu Valley in 1996
even tried to put a dollar and cent figure on the health impact of air
pollution. It calculated that in
1990, the monetary impact of pollution (mainly through deaths and
sickness) was more than Rs 200 million. This excluded the impact on
tourism and impact on intelligence due to leaded gasoline. Between 1980 and 1999,
there has been a 80 percent growth in the Valley population, the total
number of vehicles has nearly quadrupled, and there has been a staggering
300 percent increase in the number of brick kilns. Although the number of
brick kilns has remained more or less static in the past ten years, they
have become more serious polluters because of the use of low-grade coal
and urban plastic trash and tyres. The number of vehicles
which increased at an average of 15 percent a year in the 1990s, has seen
a sharp rise to 25 percent today. Total motorcycles and scooters with
two-stroke engines, grew from 30,000 in 1990 to 120,000 in 1999. One comparison done by M.
L. Shrestha in 1995 shows that (see figure) Said the Urbair
report: “Suspended particles are the primary air pollution problem in
the Valley, leading to both potential health risks and to visibility.” By the late 1990s,
the number of days with good visibility at noon had gone down to 0-2 days.
Sources at the airport say this has sharply increased the number of
morning arrival cancellations and aborted landings by big jet aircraft in
winter. The impact on air
traffic is especially glaring because the brick kilns are concentrated on
the southern approach path to the runway at Tribhuvan International
Airport. The dust pollution
is exacerbated in winter by kathmandu Valley’s bowl-shaped topography
which creates severe temperature inversion trapping warm, polluted surface
air beneath a blanket of colder air during the dry winter months. The inversion layer is
not dispersed till late afternoon because of the lack of wind and also
because the growing population, vehicles and industries have made surface
pollution worse. The worst areas for
dust contamination in Kathmandu remain the main road corridors of
Kathmandu along Kantipath, Putali Sadak, Lazimpat, the uphill to Pulchowk
and the Baneswor intersection on the Airport road. Before you start thinking
of moving to the outskirts, find out more about dispersal of brick kiln
dust and Chobar cement factory dust dispersal throughout the valley.
Swanky new millionaire residential areas in Godavari and Bhaisepati are
downwind from the worst dust emitters, and levels of dust there can be as
bad as the city center depending on the direction of prevailing winds. Toran Sharma says while
dust is the main culprit, Kathmandu’s urban planners must also keep a
close watch on carbon monoxide, which is growing alarmingly mainly because
of the proliferation of scooters and motorcycles. Although carbon monoxide levels on Kathmandu sidewalks are five times higher than 1993 levels, they are still within the WHO threshold. “But if it grows at this rate, we will be at serious risk of carbon monoxide pollution. And it will not just be the roadsides that will be affected,” says Sharma. (From
the Nepali Times Demo issue, upload date: June 25/00) Kathmandu
Gets Facelift Kathmandu may be fast becoming renowned for its squalour, but the city's residents and visitors are now getting visual pick-me-ups in pocket gardens that are sprouting all over the city. A new initiative called the Public-Private Partnership Programme - 4P for short - has marigolds and snap dragons jostling for space in traffic islands, and has even given King Tribhuvan's statue in Tripureswor a much needed face-lift. The 4P is a joint 'city beautification' project of the Kathmandu Metropolitan City (KMC) and the private businesses. So far it has transformed seven ugly traffic islands in Kathmandu into small but colourful public gardens. Built at a total cost of Rs 1,613,000, the seven traffic islands need Rs 722,000 to maintain every year. Under the 4P, private businesses shoulder the costs of garden development and maintenance while the KMC provides design, supervision and water. Surya Tobacco has adopted King Tribhuvan's statue and the traffic island around it, Hotel Association of Nepal and Nepal Association of Travel Agent are maintaining the Maiti Ghar intersection, Chabahil Junction has been handed over to the Tourist Guide Association, and Aqua Water is doing Mahankalthan Road. Agreements are pending with Nepal Tourism Board, Israel Embassy, Rotary Club and Mittal Tea. "Our involvement in the beautification activities is a combination of attempts to contribute something good to society and boost the hotel industry in the long run," says Narendra Bajracharya of Hotel Association of Nepal (HAN), a pioneer in the partnership. The KMC expects to complete 13 such other projects in 11 Kathmandu localities by October at an estimated cost of Rs 3,175,000, and private parties have already agreed to be involved. However, the eye sore at Tin Kune on the airport road is not in the beautification list since the land has been under litigation for over 10 years. "I took it as a personal challenge," says Rinchin Yonzon of the KMC, who designed the 4P project and is implementing it. At first, the 4P was met with a pinch of scepticism. After all, Kathmandu has had a surfeit of ambitious urban development plans since the 1960s--most of these have ended up in the archives of government offices, where they have been gathering dust. This is even as the government spends nearly 30 percent of its total development budget within the 600 sq km area of the Kathmandu Valley. There are also as many as 160 government bodies whose express purpose is to work on Kathmandu's urban development. Yet in the past, the municipality's idea of making Kathmandu "clean and green" was usually to merely paint pedestrian fences green, or stack flowerpots on police traffic pedestals. Other similar projects also attracted big businesses eager for the publicity, but not for the long-term attention such initiatives needed. KMC itself is still reeling from the controversy whipped up by its attempt beautify the Darahara and Sundhara area. The move drew flak after a private company was asked to manage the 25,000 sq ft area and operate a café. The local Sudhara Rehabilitation Committee took the matter to the Supreme Court, arguing against the "commercialisation" of a historical area and alleging that Mayor Keshab Sthapit had personal interest in the arrangement. The Court has yet to decide on the case. Meanwhile, a part of the Dharhara garden that was designed and built before the stay order has gone to ruins. The traffic island gardens are a modest step forward from previous efforts, but at least everyone agrees that they add colour and zest to an otherwise rapidly greying city. More importantly, private companies are vying to maintain them. "Community support and strict supervision made the traffic island gardens possible," says Yonzon, who can be seen most days personally supervising the upkeep of the traffic island gardens. In Bhotahity, locals have even been inspired enough to construct and maintain their own traffic island garden without the involvement of the KMC. Unfortunately, not all the 4P traffic island gardens are in bloom. The rock garden in Naya Baneswor has become rundown, the mayor blames lack of supervision by Ward 10 functionaries, and a fast food chain for breaking an agreement with the KMC. (From
the Nepali Times Demo issue, upload date: June 25/00) State of
the State Keeping the peace is expensive business. In a country where half the people live below the official poverty line, Rs 6 billion will be spent this fiscal year in policing the population. The Maoists, too, must be spending quite a bit waging their so-called Peoples’ War. One has to add up the two totals to grasp the magnitude of madness afflicting the nation. And there are some things cannot be measured in rupees: nearly 2,000 Nepalis have been killed fighting each other in the past five years. The loss in investor confidence, the loss of productivity, the internally displaced, and the loss that will be felt if tourism is hurt. The dictatorship of the proletariat is as distant a dream as ever, and the government has not been able to develop any kind of a peace strategy. Meanwhile, the country continues to burn, and nobody in Kathmandu seems to be too bothered. That is strange, because the price of making peace is often a lot less than the cost of keeping it. Perhaps there are influential interests who make short-term benefit from the conflict, and don’t want to wait around for the long-term possibility of a peace dividend. Comrade Prachanda apparently does not want the conflict to end, either, for it will imply an end of his dictatorial days. A general is always interested in war. Peace is for politicians, and Dr. Baburam Bhattarai is more at home in that territory. Unfortunately, for common Nepalis, the venerated architect-planner appears to have less of a say in the decision-making processes within the Maoist fold than is commonly believed. The possibility that the Maoists are serious about peace appears bleak. Comrade Prachanda will not come to the negotiating table with any sincerity unless he is cornered—partly because he himself does not seem to know what it is that he exactly wants. The onus for taking an initiative for talking lies on former prime minister and Nepali Congress leader Sher Bahadur Deuba. But Deuba too is distracted: he needs numbers to face the impending organisational elections of Nepali Congress where he is likely to be a presidential candidate. So you can be sure he is not going to make any earthshaking breakthrough before autumn. A government that lacks the self-confidence of enforcing its own laws is less likely to opt for the negotiating table. Prime Minister Girija Prasad Koirala may chant the mantra of talks, but look at where he has put the money: in an expensive para-military force trained by the army and equipped with automatic weapons. If home-made bombs and vintage .303 rifles cause such mayhem already, the casualty rates from AK-47s are sure to go up. Making peace is easier when attitudes exist which reinforce peace. The atmosphere in the country is quite the contrary. The extreme right wants the King back where the action is. Intellectuals sing paeans in praise of democracy, but show little patience for political leaders and end up undermining the system. With the population growing at 2.5 percent, and the economy at only about 3.9 percent annually, Nepal has a large pool of unemployed youths who have nothing to lose, and will take up guns at the slightest instigation. The situation is already so bad that even if Comrade Prachanda were to ask his band of desperados to lay down arms as part of a peace deal, there may be many who will still defy him for want of an alternative occupation. But peace still has a chance, for the simple reason that nothing else ever works. Comrade Prachanda must realise that he has already made a point by exposing the shards of an unjust society: oppressed citizens who are ready to risk all because they hardly have anything anyway. And it should be clear to Sher Bahadur Deuba that his political future hinges on the outcome of his talks with the Maoists. If he succeeds, he will hailed as a saviour. (A failure is unlikely to disappoint his detractors inside his party—they seem to be taking that outcome as forgone conclusion.)) Making peace is no less important for Prime Minister Koirala. There can hardly be a more fitting last hurrah for a man who has spent nearly six decades fighting for democracy and in active politics. Deputy Prime Minister Ram Chandra Paudel has earned his spurs by negotiating successfully with stubborn opposition parties. If he wants to reach where he believes he is destined to reach, he has to use those skills in getting the Maoists out of the terraces to the table. But don’t hold your breath. Serious peace efforts are unlikely to emerge until and unless the crisis of leadership in Nepali Congress is over. For that to happen, the party convention needs to take place in November. There is an old Nepali
proverb which says: “When the hut is on fire the fire-fighters wait for
the auspicious astrological time to put it out.” That kind of sums up
the state of affairs inside the Nepali Congress. The long-suffering
people of Nepal will have to exercise some more of that great gift which
they have historically shown to have in plenty: patience. (Upload date: June
30/00) Patan
Amasses Tourist Stash
More Bad Press for RAOn the eve of Royal
Nepal’s 42nd anniversary, a prestigious international business newspaper
has published an article severely criticising the airline’s
international service. “Royal Nepal Treats
Passengers like Peasants,” is the title of the recent WSJ article. In the story, Miriam
Jordan, the New-Delhi based reporter of the Wall Street Journal recounts
her experience with Royal Nepal flights in and out of Kathmandu, telling
just how bad its services have become. “As a long-time
resident of India, I have endured some painful trips on other carriers,”
she writes. “But Royal Nepal's disdain for its passengers' needs went
beyond the bounds of normal delays and tattered airport lounges,” she
adds. Jordan’s revelation is
nothing new to long-suffering Nepali passengers who have similar horror
stories to tell but did not have access to international media. Royal Nepal officials say
its infamous delays are due lack of enough aircraft—its nights flights
to New Delhi are notoriously late—but every decision it has made to
lease one has been embroiled in allegations of rampant corruption. Privately Royal Nepal
managers say there is too much government interference in the management
of the company especially in decisions about aircraft purchase or hire. “We always listen
carefully to what our well-wishers have to say about us and take proper
measures to solve their complaints and comments,” Hari Bhakta Shrestha,
executive chairman of Royal Nepal Airlines Corporation said in an
interview in the Kathmandu
Post published Saturday. “Once the aircraft issue is
solved, the complaints will be minimal,” he adds. Nepali Times brings you the full text of the WSJ story in order to help inform RA decision makers about just how bad its services have become: Royal Nepal Airlines
Treats Passengers Like Peasants A few days later, on my
last day in Nepal, I called Royal Nepal to check on the status of the 6
p.m. flight to New Delhi. The airline had told my hotel that the flight
was on time. When I pressed an airline official for the expected departure
time, he told me it was delayed -- he guessed by an hour and a half.
"But you still must check in at 4 p.m.," he added, despite my
protests. Then the wait began.
Other travellers hadn't been told about the delay--even when they checked
in. The only departure-information panel was switched off. At 6:10 p.m., a
loudspeaker blared that the flight would depart at 7:30 p.m. Passengers flocked to the
duty-free liquor shop, as well as the snack bar and candy stand. A German
couple sitting next to me peeled bananas and stuffed them between slices
of white bread. Finally, the flight
lifted off at 8:40 p.m. The woman sitting next to me, Rita Singh, appeared
tense. She had cut short her Nepal visit upon hearing that her husband was
hospitalised after being injured in a car accident back home in Canada.
Now, she was in danger of missing her Air India connection to Bombay and
then to New York en route to Toronto. Mrs. Singh's chances
weren't looking good: Not only were flights out of India stuffed to the
gills, but the Royal Nepal staff also wasn't helping her get a message to
Air India, or, after landing in New Delhi, rushing her to the front of the
line at passport control. The next day, I flew
Buddha Air, a private, domestic Nepalese airline, to a small town in
southwestern Nepal. The flight left on time. Two days later, I returned to
Kathmandu on private carrier Necon Air, and again the flight was on time. Later that day, it was
back to Kathmandu airport for a Royal Nepal flight that I have been told
was on time. At the check-in counter, an airline official wasn't so sure.
"Let's hope," he said. "The aircraft is here." No airline official was
in sight. The flight eventually departed at 8:40 (just like my last
journey). This time, my neighbour on the flight missed his train to Jaipur. "We hope to start
operating one more Boeing in July," says N.R. Sharma, administrative
manager for the airline in New Delhi. Adding to the urgency for
Royal Nepal, travellers once again have a choice. Indian Airlines resumed
service to Nepal on June 1. Rasul Bailay contributed to this article. (Upload date: July 1/00) Post-Mortem of Cargo Jet Crash A series of human errors caused the crash of a Lufthansa Cargo aircraft soon after takeoff one year ago from Kathmandu airport which killed five people, according to a report prepared by a group investigating the accident. The Boeing 727 slammed on Chandragiri Range less than three minutes after taking off loaded with carpets. The report blamed the pilots who died in the crash and Kathmandu’s Air Traffic Control (ATC). The air traffic controllers who were on duty that day are still at their jobs at Kathmandu’s radar centre. The commission, made up of senior legal and aviation officials from Nepal, India and Germany was explicit about the mistakes made by the pilots, who strayed off the standard instrument departure course. The air traffic controllers at the radar, who should have warned the pilots that they were two miles off course, failed to do so. Narendra Kumar Shrestha, a senior government lawyer who headed the commission, said there was simply no one around at the radar screens to warn the pilots. “The shifts were being changed at the time,” Shrestha said. ATC had cleared flight DLH 8533 to fly “Dharke I-A” Standard Instrument Departure, which requires all departing aircraft to make a tight climbing turn within a four-mile arc from the airport. After reaching 7,500 feet, the planes then have to turn due west to head out of the valley. Instrument departures allow planes to clear the mountains on the valley rim even when visibility is bad. “Pilots know that flying beyond four miles is to invite death,” said Shrestha. The 727 is a older-generation airplane that does not have the higher rates of climb of more recent models. Therefore, 727s carry out the “Dharke I-B” departure, which entails a cork-screw turn above the airport. But on July 7, 1999 the pilots of the ill-fated plane decided to take a “Dharke I-A”. The reason is not clear, usually this is done if the plane is not fully loaded. But the investigation revealed that the plane was 24 hours late on arrival and there was a further two-hour delay on departure from Kathmandu. Further, the American captain and the co-pilot were flying only for the second time together to Kathmandu, and both pilots were in a hurry for appointments with family members in Dubai and Delhi. The aircraft was jointly operated by Lufthansa and India’s Hinduja company. The investigation also blamed “inadequate intra-cockpit crew coordination and communication and the incorrect and slow response to the initial and subsequent GPW (ground proximity warning) system” about 36 seconds before impact. What this means is that the plane was unable to gain height, possibly because of a steeper-than-usual right bank after takeoff, and pilots were busy trying to get the airspeed up after the GPW warning when the anti-stall stick-shake activated 11 seconds later. The plane hit the mountain at 7,235 ft while falling at 250 ft per minute and in 34degree right-bank turn. The accident was technically a “controlled flight into terrain”. Police located the plane several hours after the crash but there were no survivors. Aviation experts say that although the death toll in the accident was not high, the disaster has important lessons for other regular airline flights out of Kathmandu with full loads of passengers. “We have to get to the bottom of the Lufthansa crash to prevent more serious accidents in future,” said one Nepali aviation expert. “And the key question here is why were the controllers at the radar not able to warn the pilots that they were straying beyond four miles.” The investigation also concluded as much: “No advisory alert was given by the Approach Controller to the crew when the aircraft deviated from the SID.” The report makes the following observations about Kathmandu ATC: - Arrange relief breaks with overlapping duty periods of ATCs - Emergency radio frequencies which are out of order should be fixed - ATC’s audio recording was not serviceable on July 7, it should be fixed. - Approach radar screens should have a clearly-marked 4-mile arc. - All controllers must use headsets during their hot chair position. - Intercom facilities should be restored within the ATC. (Upload date: July 2/00) NEPALiterature Bimal Nibha and the Reader Manjushree Thapa Scanning the audience at readings and literary events, counting the sales of novels or short story or poetry collections, hearing Kathmandu "intellectuals" admit that they haven't bought a literary book for years, it sometimes seems that the audience for contemporary Nepali literature consists largely of Nepali writers and poets themselves. The reading public may be blamed for this; it may be accused of a preference for unrefined pursuits such as tele-serials, useless chatter, and disco dancing. More seriously, we Nepalis are rarely taught to love reading; we do not grow up with books around us, we do not get into the habit of enjoying the imaginary worlds books create. As adults, we still approach books with the dread inspired by childhood textbooks. The publishing industry must also share the blame for low readership. Distribution and marketing is dismal when it comes to works of literature. Just as bad, most publishing houses have no editors; and so highly esteemed writers can get away with publishing whole books with only four or five strong pieces, leaving readers to flounder in much dross. Critics, with their cliques and biases, also do much to discourage the reading of literature. Reading evaluations, one often learns more about a critic's preferences than about the merits and flaws of the book discussed. Writers, too, must be held responsible for failing to attract readers. Often, Nepal's contemporary writers and poets do not work hard enough to say something true to the complexity of our lives. Laxmi Prasad Devkota's example of revising nothing has become the norm here-much to the disservice of readers. Too often, literary works recycle public opinion instead of offering the rare, unique insight that we turn to them for. Either they use an insipid, uninspired language or they affect a language so stylized that it does not touch us, affect us, or change us. Simply put, writers and poets don't seem to care much whether anyone is listening to them. Bimal Nibha is one poet who intentionally
reaches out to a living, breathing audience by understanding the everyday
language of his readers and allowing them to understand his. In Slipper,
below, he speaks, in an unassuming and perplexed voice, of the difficulty
of living in dignity more than a decade after the establishment of
democracy. He neither lectures to his readers nor purports to feel more
deeply than they-a fatal flaw in much progressive writing. Instead he
finds a voice that is natural but also deeply evocative, quiet,
questioning and occasionally fanciful. What results is an New Roads' Board Bill Parrots as Pundits
|
![]() |
| Great bread awaits you in Manang (Pic: S. Subedi) |
As you get closer, you will also be able to make out the delicate smells of brownies, breads and even hot pizzas. You steer with your nose and let the smell guide you into the village and along narrow, inclined cobblestone streets.
Sure enough, the olfactory signals take you to Bharka Bakery. Inside, the smell of hot bread mixed with brewed coffee is cosy, dry and warm. This place would be unique even in Thamel, but here at the edge of the galaxy, it is out of this world.
Tensing Gurung owns Bharka Bakery. He is used to the surprised smiles of tired trekkers who stumble in. "I don't have to drag my customers in, the smell does that, and once inside, they are glued to the cakes and bakes," he says.
In the past few years, bakeries have been sprouting like muffins across the Manang Valley. But the record-holder and pioneer must be Mesong Gurung, who 10 years ago set up a bakery right on top of Thorung La at 4,500 m.
In the laconic ways of the Manang people, Mesong understates his contribution: "There was no doubt that a bakery would do well in this remote valley. The only problem is the transport of flour." All of it comes from Pokhara and is transported from from Besisahar by mules.
The online guide, yetizone.com, also has some nice things to say about the bakeries in Manang: "The cakes in here are absolutely world class. The coffee is heavenly.
Moving up from Bharka to Manang, you are greeted by more bakeries. Since the monsoon has already arrived, the trekking traffic has thinned, but this is possibly the best time to be in Manang since the rains don't really reach up here and there are fewer crowds.
The bakery's only problem is the seasonality of the trekking traffic. "We need to have other businesses running side by side, we can't depend just on the bakery," says Karma Gurung of the Tilicho Hotel.
About 10,000 trekkers on the Annapurna circuit visit Manang every year during the two seasons: March-May and September-November. (Upload date: July 14/00)
| Send your comments and letters to the editor at editors@nepalitimes.com 1999 © Mercantile Communications Pvt. Ltd. P.O. Box 876, Durbar Marg, Kathmandu, NEPAL. Tel : 977 1 220 773, 243566, Fax: 977 1 225 407. Reproduction in any form is prohibited without prior permission. No part of the articles which appear in the internet version on Nepali Times may be reproduced without the permission of Mercantile Communications Pvt. Ltd. For reprinting rights, please write to US. Send us your feedback: CONTACT US ABOUT US HOME ADVERTISE WITH US CLICK HERE FOR PAST ISSUES |